Which do you like better?

[geogirl.livejournal.com]

I found out last week that we are having a little girl. My husband and I have two names that we like:

Caroline Grace
Allison Grace

I'm partial to Caroline and he's partial to Allison. Our daughter's name is Madelyn Elizabeth. I really want another classic girl name with 3 syllables. I also prefer not to use nicknames (ie Maddie), which is the main reason I prefer Caroline to Allison. With Allison I would have a hard time not wanting to call her Ally, but I feel like if I call her Ally, then people will take it upon themselves to call Madelyn Maddie. That may be silly, I know!

Grace is a wildly popular middle name, but it also happens to be the first name of my husband's grandma and she will be very pleased. Elizabeth is both my middle name and my grandma's middle name, so we wanted to honor his side this time.

Tell me what you think!